Thursday, September 21, 2023
FMTRADES PEOPLE
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Finance
  • Markets
  • Commodities
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Trading
  • Investing
  • Forex Trading
  • ETFs
FMTRADES PEOPLE
No Result
View All Result
Home Cryptocurrency

Drivechains Are Stupid, Prove Me Wrong

by FM Tradespeople
September 13, 2023
in Cryptocurrency
0
Drivechains Are Stupid, Prove Me Wrong
152
SHARES
1.9k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter



Shinobi’s Strawman is a weekly sequence the place our Technical Editor Shinobi challenges the Bitcoin neighborhood, aiming to fire up dialog round heated technical debates.

______________________________________________________________

We’re going to strive one thing of an experiment immediately.

Drivechains are being proclaimed by some because the savior of Bitcoin, the reply to all of its issues. It solves the long term security budget, permits complete freedom to incorporate new features into Bitcoin, and presents no downsides for present Bitcoin customers.

Sounds too good to be true? It’s:

1) Drivechains Change Miner Incentives

Drivechains introduce a hodgepodge of recent variables into miners’ incentives, and after introducing that instability advocates push for users simply adopting a degraded security model for all new use cases and functionality by using a sidechain in lieu of changing the base layer. How is that this any completely different than an outright assault on Bitcoin self custody?

2) Present Sidechains Have No Adoption

There have been many alternative design proposals for sidechains over time, however the one presently deployed ones are run by federations (Liquid and RSK), each of which have failed to realize any significant degree of adoption since they have been deployed. Does this imply sidechains should not value continued improvement effort? Or are they value it, and the failure of federated chains to be adopted is solely the results of shortcomings in that particular sidechain design?

3) Drivechains Exacerbate The Dangers Of MEV

MEV is one thing that’s doable on Bitcoin already, as systems like Stacks are demonstrating, however presently the types of MEV doable on Bitcoin are both generated by completely unbiased altcoins like Stacks (which traditionally have trended to an insignificant proportion of miners’ revenue, like Namecoin), or very low within the degree of complexity (like frontrunning Inscriptions). Drivechains open the door to arbitrarily complicated types of MEV on sidechains, whereas additionally making certain that the token producing that MEV is pegged to the worth of Bitcoin. I.e. it can’t merely fade away to an irrelevant fraction of miner revenue as folks cease shopping for an altcoin. This drastically worsens the dangers and potential harm of MEV on Bitcoin.

4) No, Swap Markets Aren’t An Reply

Paul Sztorc replied to a few of these concerns on Twitter, however these responses do not likely deal with the basis points. Swap markets may sound like a solution, however the actuality is that these simply shove the liquidity necessities onto yet one more celebration, assuming they may present huge quantities of liquidity for nearly nothing in return. That may work for small scale utility customers, or having liquidity out there to arbitrage uncertainty across the peg, I don’t suppose it is a foregone conclusion that sufficient liquidity to cowl the “answer to the safety funds downside” with out slippage is a given, to say nothing of all the opposite customers who would need to swap out and in. He then goes on to disregard the distinction between a mainchain reorg, which requires redoing work and vitality expenditure, versus a sidechain reorg which doesn’t. Lastly, he equates a random particular person for no logical or revenue pushed cause giving cash away with somebody producing a revenue with an exercise they’re the only real gatekeepers of.

Look, finally, I’m a Bitcoin maximalist. I need what’s finest for Bitcoin.

I feel drivechains are silly, harmful and a waste of time, however I need to hear your ideas on the topic. Am I fallacious concerning the factors above? Is there one more reason that I needs to be towards drivechains that I’ve neglected?

Please don’t write to me with some random hopium. I’m open to novel opinions. I need the dialog to progress. Above is my finest summation – we merely aren’t wherever near a significant consensus on drivechains.

My DMs are open. Opinion@bitcoinmagazine.com. Let’s hash it out.





Source link

Tags: DrivechainsproveStupidWrong
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Aluminium price slump ‘nearing a bottom’ as clean energy demand rises

Aluminium price slump ‘nearing a bottom’ as clean energy demand rises

August 30, 2023
5 wins for UPS workers that could influence pay, standards for others

5 wins for UPS workers that could influence pay, standards for others

August 21, 2023
The AI wave will only benefit smart stockpickers

The AI wave will only benefit smart stockpickers

August 20, 2023
Investors pulling money out of stock ETFs for first time in a year

Investors pulling money out of stock ETFs for first time in a year

August 22, 2023
German minister proposes tougher rules on Chinese foreign direct investment

German minister proposes tougher rules on Chinese foreign direct investment

0
HBAR, OP, INJ and RUNE flash bull signals as Bitcoin price looks for stability

HBAR, OP, INJ and RUNE flash bull signals as Bitcoin price looks for stability

0
Lessons from the ‘tanker war’ for Ukraine

Lessons from the ‘tanker war’ for Ukraine

0
Introducing Roger, A New Online Bank For Military Recruits

Introducing Roger, A New Online Bank For Military Recruits

0
Grayscale’s Crypto Fund Discounts Extend Far Beyond Bitcoin

Grayscale’s Crypto Fund Discounts Extend Far Beyond Bitcoin

September 21, 2023
BTCUSD Rebound Tested by 50-day SMA

BTCUSD Rebound Tested by 50-day SMA

September 21, 2023
USDJPY 20 SEP 2023 – TRADE WITH THE AMAZING COMBO ITALO PIVOTS, ITALO VOLUME AND ITALO TREND INDICATOR – Analytics & Forecasts – 20 September 2023

USDJPY 20 SEP 2023 – TRADE WITH THE AMAZING COMBO ITALO PIVOTS, ITALO VOLUME AND ITALO TREND INDICATOR – Analytics & Forecasts – 20 September 2023

September 21, 2023
Kraft is recalling some American cheese slices over potential choking hazard : NPR

Kraft is recalling some American cheese slices over potential choking hazard : NPR

September 21, 2023

Live Prices

Recent News

Grayscale’s Crypto Fund Discounts Extend Far Beyond Bitcoin

Grayscale’s Crypto Fund Discounts Extend Far Beyond Bitcoin

September 21, 2023
BTCUSD Rebound Tested by 50-day SMA

BTCUSD Rebound Tested by 50-day SMA

September 21, 2023

Categories

  • Business
  • Commodities
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Economy
  • ETFs
  • Finance
  • Forex Trading
  • Investing
  • Markets
  • Trading

Recommended

  • Grayscale’s Crypto Fund Discounts Extend Far Beyond Bitcoin
  • BTCUSD Rebound Tested by 50-day SMA
  • USDJPY 20 SEP 2023 – TRADE WITH THE AMAZING COMBO ITALO PIVOTS, ITALO VOLUME AND ITALO TREND INDICATOR – Analytics & Forecasts – 20 September 2023
  • Kraft is recalling some American cheese slices over potential choking hazard : NPR
  • Readers React To Drivechain Incentive Concerns

© 2023 FMTRADES PEOPLE | All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Finance
  • Markets
  • Commodities
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Trading
  • Investing
  • Forex Trading
  • ETFs

© 2023 FMTRADES PEOPLE | All Rights Reserved